Wheel of Analytical Meditation

The Wheel of Analytical Meditation That Thoroughly Purifies Mental Activity

by Mipham Rinpoche

Namo mañjuśrīye![1]

Whatever problems there are in the world
Are created by the afflictions in our own minds.
A mistaken attitude is a cause for the kleśas,
Yet the pattern of our thoughts can be refined.

Here there are three sections: 1) how to meditate, 2) the measure of progress, and 3) the significance of the practice.

1. How to Meditate

Multiplicity

Imagine someone who stirs in you intense attachment,
And consider them now present vividly before you.
Separate this person into five component skandhas,
And begin by investigating the physical body.

Consider all its impure substances
Of flesh and blood, bones, marrow, fat,
Internal organs, limbs and organs of sense,
Faeces, urine, bacteria, hair, nails and the like,
And the components of earth and other elements.

Think of all these aspects, each of which
Can still be divided even further, and then,
Down to the very tiniest particle,
Mentally dissect them all stage by stage,
Checking whether you feel desire for each in turn.

Since there is nothing we could call “body”
Apart from these substances, varied and impure,
A body is just like an unclean contraption,
A field of grass, wall of bricks, mound of waste,
Or a mass of bubbling foam.

Seeing this fact, sit and consider it mindfully.
Once the momentum of this insight fades,
Turn to feelings, perceptions, formations and consciousness,
And look into their nature,
By dividing them into their various aspects.

When you see them as insubstantial like bubbles,
A mirage, a plantain tree or a magical illusion,
You will understand how in these too there is nothing
To which one could ever be attached.
Continue with this thought until it fades.
Then, once it does, do not try to prolong it,
But turn instead to another investigation.

Impermanence

Reflect deeply on how these aggregates,
Which are impure and lack real essence,
Do not remain once they have arisen,
But perish from one moment to the next.

All the civilizations and societies of the past,
Met with only destruction in the end,
And so will those of today and ages yet to come.
The nature of the conditioned can inspire disenchantment.

Death is certain for all living things,
Suddenly it comes, and without warning.
Reflect on how all that we experience in life
Is changing from one moment to the next.

In summary, to the best of your ability,
Consider all the aspects of impermanence
That characterize conditioned things.
Reflect on each in turn with lucid thoughts.

Recognize how the aggregates of those that we desire,
Are transient as lightning, evanescent like bubbles,
And fleeting like clouds in the sky.
Until the momentum of this idea fades,
Focus your attention on nothing else.

Suffering

Then consider how within each of the aggregates,
Which are momentary and consist of many aspects,
There are experiences we might describe as pain itself,
And those that seem pleasant until they change.

Yet they all provide the cause for future woes,
And thus the skandhas are the basis of suffering.
Reflect as well, as much as you are able,
On all the misery there is within the world.

All is due to the skandhas’ imperfections.
There is not the tiniest speck or pin-tip’s worth
Of these contaminated aggregates
That is free from the defect of suffering.

As they are the source of suffering,
The skandhas are likened to a filthy swamp,
A pit of burning coals or an island of demons.
Remain with this insight for as long as you can.

Selflessness

Finally, investigate these aggregates,
Which have many aspects and are impermanent,
And whose suffering nature has now been shown,
And look for what it is that we call “I.”

When you see that, like a waterfall,
A shower of rain or an empty house,
They are devoid of any intrinsic self,
Remain until this conviction fades.

When it does disappear, then once again
Investigate in the stages as they have been shown.
Sometimes contemplate in no particular sequence,
Or else investigate a variety of things.

Practise investigating these points again and again,
Sometimes considering another’s aggregates,
Sometimes looking into your own,
And at times, analyzing all that is conditioned.
Let your attachment to anything be undermined.

In short, renounce any thought that does not
Involve an investigation of these four points,[2]
And turn the wheel of analysis again and again.
The more you analyze, the more your certainty will grow.

Apply therefore a clear mind of intelligence
To all kinds of observations just like these,
And, like wildfire spreading across a grassy plain,
Practise continually without interruption.

Say to yourself: “In the past, I would always
Get caught in my mistaken ideas and attitudes,
Which led to all kinds of useless speculation,
But now I will consider only this instead.”

If you find yourself getting tired,
Yet notice that the afflictions still do not arise,
Even without your applying the antidote,
Then rest in equanimity to refresh your mind.

After a while, once your tiredness is no more,
Repeat the investigation just like before,
At all times being mindful and aware
Of the insight the investigation brings.

If, at times, you slip into forgetfulness,
And the afflictions have occasion to arise,
Then take up this investigation once more,
Like reaching for a weapon when enemies appear.

Just as light will banish darkness,
It is almost needless to say that
A precise investigation such as this,
Even if it is only practised a little,
Will do great harm to the kleśas.

However much one understands the flaws
Of this conditioned saṃsāric world,
One will also understand the unconditioned,
Nirvāṇa’s supreme and refreshing peace.

2. The Measure of Progress

Eventually, through familiarity with this practice,
You will naturally appreciate how everything
Included within the five skandhas and the conditioned
Is manifold, impermanent, painful and devoid of self.

Even without any deliberate effort,
The whole of your experience
Will seem magical and insubstantial,
And you will overcome the kleśas.

When it is free from the waves of the afflictive emotions,
The ocean of your mind is made serene and calm.
This is conducive to gaining mental self-control,
Through which one reaches the samādhi of calm abiding.

If you can then look into the very identity
Of the mind in one-pointed concentration,
That is the extraordinary insight of vipaśyanā.

It is here that one finds the initial entry point
That is common to all three vehicles.

3. The Significance of the Practice

All illusory phenomena which arise interdependently,
Have never arisen since the very dawn of time,
And so in emptiness—the lack of phenomenal identity—
They are beyond extremes such as sameness or difference.

This absolute space of great indivisible equality,
Is also known as the essence of the sugatas.
Once it is realized, one finds the great nirvāṇa
That abides in neither existence nor quiescence.

This is supremely pure and blissful,
The great unconditioned, totally permanent,
The great self-identity—these are its
Transcendent and unsurpassable qualities.

This is the theme of the highest secret essence tantras,
The all-pervading space of ultimate co-emergent bliss,
It is also referred to as ‘naturally arising wisdom',
A state in which all phenomena have total perfection.
To introduce this directly through the master’s
Pith instructions is the approach of the Great Perfection.

Therefore, as a preliminary training
For the mahāyāna path of both sūtra and mantra,
Breaking through the shell of confusion surrounding the conditioned,
This path of precise investigation is excellent indeed.

First, through the power of fine analysis,
One destroys the marks of rising afflictions.
Then through confidence in the emptiness of the aggregates,
One lets go of desires and hopes based on the three realms,
And eventually, by progressing in stages, all conceptual notions
Are pacified completely within the state of emptiness.

Not wishing for any antidotes or further relinquishing,
One is freed entirely from attachment and clinging to extremes.
With the purest compassion beyond attachment,
One courses through existence without the slightest fear,
Like a bird soaring through absolute space,
And attains the level of a supreme bodhisattva.

Based on the statements of noble masters, I have here explained
The important points of the paths of the three vehicles,
Which provide a thorough purification of mental activity,
As a preliminary to the paths of śamatha and vipaśyanā.

The more familiar you become with this practice
Of thoroughly purifying activities of the mind,
The more the afflictions will diminish,
And the subtler the kleśas will become.

This will make it easier to practise śamatha,
And just like gold that is treated in fire
So it becomes malleable and ready to craft,
Mind will be refined once it is freed from attachment.

Imagine if someone were to offer plentiful gifts
To the Three Jewels for a thousand godly years.
It is said in the sūtras that the merit of this generosity
Is surpassed by the merit of even a moment’s reflection
On impermanence, emptiness and selflessness.

This is because the teachings say that
To recite the Four Seals of the Mahāyāna Dharma
Is equivalent to understanding the teachings
In the eighty-four thousand sections of the Dharma.

If you meditate well on the points explained here,
Since they bring together the key points of many thousands of sūtras,
You will easily gain the treasure of knowing perfectly the profound and vast,
And liberation will swiftly follow in its wake.

By the virtue of this explanation, may all beings
Tormented by the troubles of this degenerate age,
Meet this elixir-like teaching on non-attachment,
And, through its power, reach a state of perfect peace.

This was written by Mipham Nampar Gyalwa in the Iron Hare year [1891] on the 18th day of the tenth month.

Maṅgalam!

| Translated by Adam Pearcey, 2004, based on a version prepared by Garth Copenhaver and Adam Pearcey in 2002 through the kindness of Ringu Tulku Rinpoche. Translation revised October 2006. Thanks to Cortland Dahl of the Rimé Foundation for providing further clarifications based on the commentary of Khenpo Sherab Sangpo. Further revised with the kind assistance of Khenpo Sonam Tsewang, 2021.

Bibliography

Tibetan Sources

Mi pham rgya mtsho. "sems kyi spyod pa rnam par sbyong ba so sor brtag pa'i dpyad sgom 'khor lo ma/" in: gsung 'bum/_mi pham rgya mtsho. TBRC W23468. 27 vols. paro, bhutan: lama ngodrup and sherab drimey, 1984-1993. http://tbrc.org/link?RID=W23468 Vol. 27: 1–9

Mi pham rgya mtsho. "sems kyi spyod pa rnam par sbyong ba so sor brtag pa'i dpyad sgom 'khor lo ma/" in gsung 'bum/_mi pham rgya mtsho. TBRC W2DB16631. 32 vols. khreng tu'u: [gangs can rig gzhung dpe rnying myur skyobs lhan tshogs], 2007. http://tbrc.org/link?RID=W2DB16631 Vol. 32: 307–314

Secondary Sources

Dilgo Khyentse, The Collected Works of Dilgo Khyentse: Volume Two. Boston, MA: Shambhala Publications, 2010.

Duckworth, Douglas, S. Jamgön Mipam: His Life and Times. Boston, MA: Shambhala Publications, 2011.

Khenchen Palden Sherab Rinpoche & Khenpo Tsewang Dongyal Rinpoche, Uprooting Clinging: A Commentary on Mipham Rinpoche’s Wheel of Analytic Meditation, Dharma Samudra, 2019

Khenpo Gawang. Your Mind is Your Teacher: Self-Awakening through Contemplative Meditation. Boston, MA: Shambhala Publications, 2013.

Lama Mipham. Calm and Clear. trans. Keith Dowman. Berkeley, CA. Dharma Publishing, 1973

Mipham Rinpoche. "Putting the Instruction on the Purification of Mental Activity into Practice." trans. Adam Pearcey. Lotsawa House. (https://www.lotsawahouse.org/tibetan-masters/mipham/putting-analytical-meditation-into-practice)

Version: 3.1-20230724